KEI Concerns and CID AlternativeLike many folks, I have been using KEI for some time now to determine what keywords I should target with my web site. And this has led me to becoming concerned with
results KEI provides and
keywords it suggests. I need to say here that my concern is very subjective as many folks are happily using KEI and don't seem to have a problem with it.
My main concern with KEI is that, by
way it works, it strongly favours demand numbers without, I feel, sufficiently taking into account
corresponding supply numbers.
I need to say here that I interpret supply numbers as a representation of how competitive a keyword is. For example, if keyword 1 has a supply of 200,000 while keyword 2 has a supply of 5,000,000, then I would consider keyword 2 as being more competitive than keyword 1.
And all things being equal, I would prefer to target a keyword that is less competitive and with less demand, rather than a highly competitive keyword that has a higher demand. The reason for this is that I feel that I have a better chance of cornering a section of a less competitive market than I do that of a highly competitive one.
Based on my concern with KEI, I have decided to create an alternative. I have called this alternative "Competition Indexed Demand" (CID). Now, CID works out
marketing potential of keywords in a similar way to KEI but it uses a different formula, one that takes more into account
supply numbers of keywords (or their competitiveness).
For example, using "ranking" as
starting keyword with Overture, KEI suggests
following top 3 keywords,
Keyword Demand Supply KEI nfl quarterback ranking 43,474 75,800 24,934 nfl power ranking 43,171 122,000 15,277 college basketball ranking 71,149 541,000 9,357
while CID suggests
following top 3 keywords,
Keyword Demand Supply CID dick vitale college basketball ranking 16,983 33,400 640 nfl quaterback ranking 43,474 75,800 427 vote nba power ranking 3,129 30,200 394
Comparing
2 sets of results, you can see how CID favours lower competition compared to KEI. I have now used CID for quite a number of keyword research projects and have found that not only it favours lower competition, but it also suggests keywords that, I feel, have a better demand-supply balance.