Continued from page 1
A history of bad news For example, in 1994, University of Washington bioengineering professors Henry Lai and Narendra Singh found that DNA in rats' brains was damaged after two hours of exposure to levels of microwave radiation considered safe by government. When Lai and Singh published research, a leaked memo from Motorola's head of global strategy, Norm Sandler talked about ways to minimize damage by undermining their research, with Sandler writing, "I think that we have sufficiently war-gamed Lai/Singh issue." Ouch. Worse, research biologist Jerry Phillips, who was paid by Motorola to conduct similar testing, says he was able to duplicate Lai and Singh's findings, but was then asked not to publish research and was subsequently shunned by company. Motorola says it told Phillips that his findings needed clarification, and industry still maintains that Lai and Singh's results have never been duplicated and can't be considered legitimate.
The biggest Russell Crowe-style insider in this case, though, is Dr. George Carlo, who was hired by Cellular Telecommunications & Internet Association to head up a $28 million research program into possible health effects from cellular phones. Unfortunately, he now says his findings show an increased rate of brain cancer deaths, development of tumors, and genetic damage among heavy cell phone users. He wrote this letter of concern to president of AT&T Corporation and later went public with his findings after what he considered to be neglect by industry. He's since broken with industry, become a vocal critic, and coauthored a book called Cell Phones: Invisible Hazards in Wireless Age--so you can tell he's on "cell phones could cause cancer" side of things.
Meanwhile, more studies keep coming, and they seem to be getting worse. A study funded by European Union reported last December that radio waves from mobile phones do, definitively, damage DNA and other cells in body--and that damage extended to next generation of cells. Even though mutated cells are considered a possible cause of cancer, UK National Radiological Protection Board said that since study didn't show that damage definitely led to disease, consumers shouldn't worry too much about findings.
Uh, right. In meantime, report recommended that children use mobile phones only in emergency situations. You know, just in case. How reassuring.
The cell phone industry hasn't commissioned another large-scale study – at least not publicly –since its fateful encounter with Dr. Carlo – and why would they? They're in a catch-22. It's a multibillion dollar industry, and they simply can't afford to find out, definitively, that cell phones are dangerous. Worse, just like tobacco companies, if they start issuing warnings and precautionary tales now, it'll look like they knew all along that radio waves were dangerous, opening them up to major liability claims. They've already dodged one big, big bullet--an $800 million lawsuit against Motorola and cell phone carriers was thrown out in 2002, with judge ruling that there wasn't sufficient evidence for trial. Since then, neurologist Dr. Christopher Newman, who filed lawsuit, has died of brain cancer.
Listen, I use a cell phone, and I'm not trying to scare bejesus out of everyone. But I do use a headset when I'm talking for any long period of time, and I carry that sucker in my purse, not my pocket. (I know you guys don't have that luxury, but reconsider briefcase, OK?) And if you're shopping for a new phone, you might want to check our cell phone radiation chart to see which ones carry a low dose.
In a few more years, we'll either know for sure that cell phones can cause cancer, or we'll know they can't. I just hope we don't find out hard way – through subpoenaed documents from cell phone makers and carriers who've been trying to minimize their damages and maximize their profits for more than a decade.
Loring Windblad worked in communications for more than 25 years and has observed first hand the harmful effects of RF radiation in near proximity to both humans and other animals. His latest business endeavor is at: http://www.organicgreens.us