Continued from page 1
American high-voltage electro-shock stun shields turned up in Turkey, stun guns in Indonesia, and electro-shock batons and shields, and dart-firing taser guns in torture-prone Saudi Arabia. American firms are
dominant manufacturers of stun belts. Explains Dennis Kaufman, President of Stun Tech Inc, a US manufacturer of this innovation: ''Electricity speaks every language known to man. No translation necessary. Everybody is afraid of electricity, and rightfully so.'' (Quoted by Amnesty International).
The Omega Foundation and Amnesty claim that 49 US companies are also major suppliers of mechanical restraints, including leg-irons and thumbcuffs. But they are not alone. Other suppliers are found in Germany (8), France (5), China (3), Taiwan (3), South Africa (2), Spain (2),
UK (2) and South Korea (1).
Not surprisingly,
Commerce Department doesn't keep tab on this category of exports.
Nor is
money sloshing around negligible. Records kept under
export control commodity number A985 show that Saudi Arabia alone spent in
United States more than $1 million a year between 1997-2000 merely on stun guns. Venezuela's bill for shock batons and such reached $3.7 million in
same period. Other clients included Hong Kong, Taiwan, Mexico and - surprisingly - Bulgaria. Egypt's notoriously brutal services - already well-equipped - spent a mere $40,000.
The United States is not
only culprit. The European Commission, according to an Amnesty International report titled "Stopping
Torture Trade" and published in 2001:
"Gave a quality award to a Taiwanese electro-shock baton, but when challenged could not cite evidence as to independent safety tests for such a baton or whether member states of
European Union (EU) had been consulted. Most EU states have banned
use of such weapons at home, but French and German companies are still allowed to supply them to other countries."
Torture expertise is widely proffered by former soldiers, agents of
security services made redundant, retired policemen and even rogue medical doctors. China, Israel, South Africa, France, Russia,
United kingdom and
United States are founts of such useful knowledge and its propagators.
How rooted torture is was revealed in September 1996 when
US Department of Defense admitted that ''intelligence training manuals'' were used in
Federally sponsored School of
Americas - one of 150 such facilities - between 1982 and 1991.The manuals, written in Spanish and used to train thousands of Latin American security agents, "advocated execution, torture, beatings and blackmail", says Amnesty International.
Where there is demand there is supply. Rather than ignore
discomfiting subject, governments would do well to legalize and supervise it. Alan Dershowitz, a prominent American criminal defense attorney, proposed, in an op-ed article in
Los Angeles Times, published November 8, 2001, to legalize torture in extreme cases and to have judges issue "torture warrants". This may be a radical departure from
human rights tradition of
civilized world. But dispensing export carefully reviewed licenses for dual-use implements is a different matter altogether - and long overdue.
