Continued from page 1
The Optimum Solution: A Blended Approach
At best,
planning process should not be at either end of
spectrum, but squarely in
middle. In my experience, plans that win funding come from a true collaboration between a skilled consultant/facilitator and
entrepreneur’s team of employees and advisors.
A business planning consultant can act as a coach, first assessing
job to be done, and then recommending who is best to do it. The business plan should be a compilation of work between
vision and goals of
entrepreneur,
technical understanding and expertise of his or her accountant and other professionals, a consensus of employees or others, and
research and writing abilities of
business planning consultant. The consultant should meet with all parties involved, talk about what is needed for
plan, and use all
resources available to get
work done as quickly and cost effectively as possible. It is
consultant’s responsibility in
process to take all
pieces and make
final plan into a readable, accessible document that will stand up to investor/lender scrutiny. My final caveats:
•Don’t pay more than a few thousand dollars for a plan unless you are looking for capital of well over $1 million. I have heard more than a few horror stories by people who have hired university professors assuming they are
experts (they aren’t) and paying tens of thousand of dollars for a poorly written or incomplete plan. Ask your banker for business planning consultant recommendations, or better yet, talk with someone who had a good experience having a business plan written for them. It is reasonable for a consultant to expect you to pay half of
fee up front and
other half at
completion of
plan. And you can’t hold
consultant responsible if you don’t get funding based on
plan – too much is based on your own credit and management skills.
•Don’t expect to get a finished plan that is a roadmap of everything you need to do to have a successful business. That isn’t
purpose of
business planning process. A traditional business plan is intended only to document your strategies for
business very briefly – but well enough to get funding. If you are hoping for something that will tell you how to market or how many people you need to hire, you will have to start with a deep strategic planning process, and probably buy lots of consulting time to get you going.
•Don’t expect a great a business plan from a poor business model. If your costs are too high to make your business profitable,
business planning process will help you discover that. Then it will be up to you to make
hard decisions about changing your costs structure to make
business work. The business planning consultant is a skilled professional, not a miracle worker. A good business plan can help you highlight your strengths and minimize your weaknesses, but it cannot make an unworkable business model into a thriving business.
And one final thought: Don’t go on to start a business or make changes in your current business if everything in
business planning process tells you it won’t work. Things don’t get better out in
real world if they don’t work on paper. Deal with
weaknesses – get more training, consider product redevelopment, or have a home-based business to reduce costs until you can sustain
rent for an office. Businesses fail finally because they’ve run out of money. If your plan tells you that you can’t make enough money to make
business work for
long run, pay attention to that reality.

Jan B. King is the former President & CEO of Merritt Publishing, a top 50 woman-owned and run business in Los Angeles and the author of Business Plans to Game Plans: A Practical System for Turning Strategies into Action (John Wiley & Sons, 2004). She has helped hundreds of businesses with her book and her ebooks, The Do-It-Yourself Business Plan Workbook, and The Do-It-Yourself Game Plan Workbook. See www.janbking.com for more information.