Continued from page 1
And advice is often manipulative.
My friend was having a party and couldn't decide whether to fill
house with flowers. A third friend launched into a whole complicated monologue about
cost of
flowers,
work involved arranging them, and so on.
The party giver's cat wandered in. I said I wouldn't pet it because I am allergic to long haired cats. The advice giver immediately sympathised.
'Oh, I am allergic to so many things, I have to avoid cats, dust mites, pollen... you name it!'
She reddened and suddenly went very quiet. Her 'advice' was based on
fact that large number of pollen-laden flowers would have spoiled
party for her!
An honest response would have been: 'flowers would make it hard for me to come to your party...'
I don't give advice to psychotherapy clients. We often need a range of options to process. I just support them in coming up with options, that's all.
Expert opinion is valuable - but
giver needs to detach from
outcome.
Practical advice is different: if water is pouring out of a burst pipe you need
person who knows
location of
stopcock!
But if someone asks for more abstract 'advice' I'll first ask what they think they should do, and if they're stuck, I'll say, 'well, you might want to look at... etc'
That leaves it open. Because hey, if it all goes wrong I don't want
responsibility of having made
decision for them!
======================================= Rhiannon Hill is
author of "10 Stupid Things That Can Screw Up Your Life" Get
no-bull self-help book that tells it like it is... http://www.bookshaker.com/product_info.php?products_id=102 =======================================

Rhiannon Hill is the author of "10 Stupid Things That Can Screw Up Your Life" Get the no-bull self-help book that tells it like it is... http://www.bookshaker.com/product_info.php?products_id=102 =======================================