Continued from page 1
While
author does a very good job of raising
important issues of power which relate to race, class, and gender, as well as sexual orientation, he seems to have little ability to rise above
immediate issue to give that promised "big picture." Instead of giving us a broader perspective on
controversies and crises that he presents so well, he tends to focus on condemning
shortsightedness, inflexibility, or selfishness of one or more of
adversary parties. The fact that he often has blame aplenty for all sides to a conflict shows evenhandedness but adds little perspective. This focus on conflict is also reflected in
profusion of war metaphors in this volume, with chapter titles of "Rallying
Troops," "The Making of Soldiers," and "War Bonds." The inutility of such "war on disease" metaphors was ably expressed by Sontag in her brilliant monograph Illness as a Metaphor.
Despite these criticisms of Victory Deferred as an integrative work, it is well worth
price for its profusion of anecdotal details and
important issues it raises and provides a degree of insight into. Even more than that, it preserves some element of
experience and wisdom of many persons interviewed for this book who are no longer with us.

Dr. David F. Duncan is the President of Duncan & Associates, a research and policy studies consulting firm in the areas of public health, mental health, and drug abuse. http://www.duncan-associates.com
His Commonplace Book is a collection of excerpts, book reviews, and commentary on classic movies and favorite authors. http://commonplacebook.tripod.com/home/